You belong here.

Let’s talk pizza. We serve Neapolitan-style pizzas, made with bold flavors and high-quality ingredients. This pizza style, born in 18th-century Naples, rocks a 12-inch crust that's light, airy, and has a thick, puffy edge. We cook it fast and hot, giving it those delicious, charred spots everyone loves. Pair that with our creative cocktails, and a variety of curated appetizes, piadinas, and entrees, and you’ve got an experience that stands out.

Absolutely! Check out the Pizzavant section of our menu. Make it yours with a special selection of toppings. There are no rules—only delicious possibilities.

Absolutely. We’re all about sourcing locally and keeping it fresh. Good food deserves good ingredients—no pretenses here.

Of course! We believe every little one deserves a slice of the good life. Check out our kids' menu packed with tasty, kid-friendly options.

No worries—we take allergies seriously. Just let your server know, and we’ll make sure you dine safely while enjoying all the flavors.

Absolutely! Our gluten-free pizza crust is here to ensure everyone can dive into the deliciousness without holding back. Many of our appetizers, salads, and entrees can also be modified to be gluten-free. However, it’s important to note that, due to the nature of our restaurant, there is a higher risk of gluten contamination compared to other food allergies. We’re happy to assist you, so just let your server know your needs, and we’ll do our best to accommodate you while you enjoy a fabulous meal!

Yes, indeed! Our full bar features wines, craft beers, and our signature cocktails, perfect for elevating your experience.

Our cocktails are crafted for those who appreciate the finer sips. From seasonal favorites to the classics, we’ve got a drink for every vibe.

We’re nestled at 345 4th Street. Directions are easy on our website or through your favorite map—it’s an adventure just waiting for you!

Parking in downtown Columbus, Indiana, is a breeze for all our visitors. You’ll find plenty of public parking lots and street spots, including metered spaces that keep things easy. Most meters take credit cards, so you can pay without a hassle. Plus, many local businesses roll out the welcome mat with designated parking for their customers. Just keep an eye out for any time restrictions or special events that might shake things up. All in all, downtown Columbus offers a simple and stress-free parking experience to make your visit even better.

We’re here to serve you Monday – Thursday  :: 11am-9pm, Friday & Saturday  :: 11am-11pm and Sunday  :: 11am-8pm. Keep an eye on our social for any surprises or special hours.

You sure can! Secure your spot through our website or give us a call. Reservations for our opening weekend will be announced soon. We can’t wait to welcome you.

Right now, we’re not offering to-go orders, but we’re thrilled to share that this service is coming your way shortly after we open! Our focus is all about delivering an exceptional dining experience, and our team is hard at work to make sure every pizza is enjoyed just as it’s meant to be—fresh out of our brick oven. Keep an eye out for updates on when our to-go service will launch, so you can indulge in our unique flavors from the comfort of your own home.

At Blacksheep, we bring you a dining experience that’s as flexible as your plans—perfect for everything from intimate get-togethers to lively celebrations! However, we do not have private dining spaces.

Our space gives us the opportunity to offer and elevate outdoor dining from March to October.

We keep it simple. All major credit cards, debit cards, and good ol’ cash are welcome here.